
EDMONTON 1
VS.
CALGARY 2
---------------
I put up the Oil City picture because of the following e-mail tips:
A friend of a friend who works at Oil City saw Hall grinding on six  chicks on the dance floor with his shirt around his head... this was on  New Years Eve... true story.  Soooo I'm getting most of the Oilers were  way too hungover to play a good game.Our effort was really weak...I can probably count on one hand the amount  of times we beat Flames dmen clean, we just weren't willing to work for  it. This was true in the defensive end as well; we just didn't want to  beat anyone tonight.
Obviously losing Eberle was a huge blow; he brings so much calm and well  executed play that we suffered without him. Renney's pregame decisions  (dressing Jacques, sitting 91, sending down Omark and not having him  available, and playing 43 over Petry specifically) handicapped us  offensively (and defensively I would argue as well) before puck drop and  we really couldn't get any kind of offensive flow going. It is true  that some of this was because the Flames were allowed to clutch and hold  all night (we had what, 1 PP?) but we also didn't force them to take us  down or hook. We weren't skating past anyone, and that's the key to  drawing penalties. It's also something 91 does better than anyone on the  roster. It'd be nice if we could give the young offence a rest  sometimes, but we're clearly not talented enough to do so and compete.
It is clear this team has problems starting games at home with  enthusiasm and focus. I'm really not sure why this is; other than that  maybe through lack of competition our roster has gotten too comfortable.  There is no actual pressure on the bottom lines because of the way we  manage players. It doesn't make a lot of sense.
The Flames are a sorry bunch right now; they just laid back all night  despite our lacking efforts in all zones. We should've been torched for 4  or 5 tonight. Our D wasn't solid and our neutral zone play was brutal,  but they didn't even look interested in playing. If Jackman doesn't  score a semi-lucky one this game probably goes 18 rounds in a SO before  Jason Strudwick falls headfirst into Kiprusoff and takes the puck in  with him. It was that BLAH tonight.
The only positive that comes out of this game is that maybe Omark gets  recalled and some entertainment value comes with him. We're not exactly  looking stellar right now in that regard.
The first Calgary goal was an utter debacle for 43, 45 and 13. All were  out of position and made bad choices. 13 needs to learn to cover  someone, ANYONE in his defensive zone. Just about every Oilers forward  on the roster is better at this than he.
The second Calgary goal was an unfortunate sequence; Hemsky and Penner  got tangled on the draw, then Hemsky didn't make it to the point while  Penner failed to lift Jokinen's stick as the puck came through.  Unfortunate play.
Our goal was a beauty; great backhand pass through Calgary D's legs to  Gilbert, who sold the shot hard and then made a great pass to Jones who  streaked into a perfect position and scored. One of the only solid  offensive outbursts of the night.
PLAYER REPORTS
-----------------
Khabibulin
- Wasn't really tested with tough shots tonight as the Flames couldn't  jump onto offence very well. He played well enough for us to have a  chance to win though, especially in the first period. No complaints.
Belle
- Though he showed some solid wheels and skated the puck alright, he  struggled more defensively than during his last go round. He kept  drifting out of position or playing a little too far from his man. I  know playing with 43 probably didn't help, but he needs to be better.  Watching him skate with the puck, I'm kind of amazed no one's ever tried  him at forward. He could be a rather interesting power-winger.
Strudwick
- There were multiple times tonight where 43 stood, looked around, then  seemed to realize that "Oh yeah, I'm playing hockey and have to move,  there's also a black disc near my feet...hmmm". He was even worse than  usual and certainly contributed to the loss. Every time Renney sent  45-43 over the boards on a shift with the first line, they managed to  bugger up the play. This is an element of coaching logic I've seen from  both MacTavish and Renney that I don't understand at all. Playing 43  over Petry might've lost us the game frankly, because with 2 more decent  breakout passes, or a decent play on the PP or opposition blue, maybe  we pop a goal or two and it is anyone's game.
Gilbert
- Struggled a little more defensively than he has in past games, but  still joined the rush and made a decent pass or three. Certainly not on  him tonight.
Peckham
- I expected a lot more from him tonight; he didn't smack the Flames  around and we needed that fairly badly. He was decently positionally and  moved the puck alright, but he could've been the X Factor in this one.
Foster
- A few more stupid shots that had no chance of going in. These might as  well have been giveaways. One thing I've noticed is he's becoming  lazier in terms of trying to rely on his reach rather than skating to  and through the puck. This is an unfortunate trend. He wasn't physical  either and didn't contribute much.
Smid
- Liked the way he was moving his feet a bunch tonight, and certainly  had an improved defensive outing. I was surprised however that he didn't  do more offensively. There was one really nice sequence he had which I  believe was late in the first, but that was it. Does anyone have any  idea why we can't teach him to use his talents to become a more  successful offensive player? All the elements are there except a plan...
Jacques-Fraser-Stortini
- Stortini doesn't look near as good playing with this group. He showed  some early jump but honestly got pushed around and then backed off a  bit. Very disappointed he couldn't follow up last game's strong effort.  I'd like to address a point that's been made about Fraser lately: I am  not ignoring his defensive game, it just doesn't impress me either. He's  not a guy that will go get the puck, win races, throw defensive hits or  make great blocks. He literally does nothing, even when he gets the  puck in clear open ice, which is just plain not good enough for anyone  on an NHL roster. Jacques made his best play tonight without a stick;  that says all you need to know about #22. He even got muscled off a puck  he was driving down the boards into the Calgary zone by a weak-ish  check from a Calgary defender he had excellent position on. What's the  point of being a big forward if you can't execute that?
Brule-O'Marra-Jones
- O'Marra was effectively benched after the Eberle injury, which I  really don't understand because he is holding his own and playing better  positionally than guys like Cogliano, Brule and Jacques. He's also a  better hockey player than Stortini most nights this year. Not sure what  Renney thinks he's doing there. Brule still didn't show me anything; no  indication that he's learned from his benching. His offensive game has  degraded and he no longer shows any boardplay or physicality. If they  won't let him take faceoffs, what else is he supposed to do? Jones  played alright after being promoted to an offensive line. It's nice to  have a guy who's versatile like that. It was also nice to see that he  kept his effort level up and didn't get frustrated like many of his  mates seemed to as the night went on. I would've liked more hitting, but  at least he could take a pass.
Hall-Gagner-Eberle
- Hall missing that breakaway killed. I don't know why he went backhand,  much less 5-hole backhand (I'm not sure there's a weaker combination in  the game), but if he finishes that chance it's a HUGE momentum swing  after Khabibulin took that STUPID penalty. He had a couple of other  chances as well, but couldn't seem to get anything going. He's also  firing wide again, and seemed to have trouble controlling the puck in  the Flames' zone. Eberle was playing fairly well before his injury,  generating a couple of our best chances. It's going to be tough watching  the games without him, but maybe this will force Renney to be a little  more original in his line combinations. Gagner was a little less visible  than usual tonight. I've noticed he often rushes up the right side  rather than the center slot with Hall and Eberle, but I'm not sure how  well this play is going to work long-term as that's a hard spot for him  to finish from.
Penner-Cogliano-Hemsky
- Cogliano tried to do too much again, and also couldn't take a pass.  Combine that with the previously noted defensive struggles and I really  hope he's off this line for my own sanity's sake. I know this might be a  nice way to gain him some tradability, but it hurts to watch. Hemsky  struggled more than usual in the offensive zone tonight, mainly because  Calgary blocked the shooting lanes very well and he got frustrated and  started to force the play a bit much. The lack of support from the blue  and Cogliano certainly didn't help, but Ales needs to be better than  tonight. Penner was just okay. He had some great moments of knocking  Flames around and making that pass, but wasn't really interested in  willing this team to a win or drilling a hole for Hemsky to score from.  Even if just these guys had been going tonight, we win.
----------
Certainly an unfortunate followup to our last 2 periods. That was the  quietest EDM-CGY Saturday game I've been to in a long time.
A note of congratulations to the SSAC club that won the Mac's Cup today.  A friend of a friend is their head coach and his boys survived a scary  penalty-filled third to win one of hockey's finest tournaments at the  Midget level. I was an MLAC man myself, but congrats to the boys on a  wonderful title.
[
BOX]